Several suspicion to RutherFord model

Several suspicion to RutherFord model

 

point:

    1⃣ how proton gather at the centor of atom, in RutherFord model ?

         how they can reduce push power of electric power within them ?

    2⃣ why powerful electron always add at outside of atom, in RutherFord model ?

        powerful electron may have more speed, so pull power from core necessary to hold them 

        when inside electrons increases, they shields protons pull power(shielding effect),

        then pull power from core to outside ~= 0

    3⃣ if electric power is the most powerful power element in physic,

         why neutron can pulls proton, more stronger than electric power?

 

several point, everyone may confuse:

    1⃣ in RutherFord experiments, we predict He²⁺ particle, not directly hit core of atom, but pushed by core with push power

    2⃣ RutherFord model, are just like

         stick magnets, to gather N poles center, & to gather S poles at outside

         He²⁺ particle ~= only N pole magnet (its not possible but to represent situation, thats may good metapher )

    3⃣ atom model, may not always same, when metal & other object have different features

(4⃣ human scientist in past sometimes hard to say elder scientist may wrong, because young human scientist have to welcomed by elder scientists. so even if they notice something wrong in theory, they wont say directly, but remain theory on wrong past theory, with some code. )

(5⃣ if electron = plus in our textbook originally, battery energy flows from plus to minus, as if learned in elementary school )

 

answerer777